6 Best Target Butts For Broadhead Testing For Longevity

Sighting in broadheads is the final, critical step in preparing for a successful hunt, yet it remains the most taxing task for any archery target. Using a standard field-point target will lead to immediate shredding, leaving broadheads dull and arrow shafts prone to structural damage. Investing in a dedicated broadhead target ensures accuracy, preserves expensive blades, and builds the confidence necessary for a clean ethical harvest.

Disclosure: This site earns commissions from listed merchants at no cost to you. Thank you!

Morrell High Roller: Best Overall Durability

The Morrell High Roller stands out due to its unique hexagonal shape and multi-faceted shooting surfaces. Its high-density foam construction is specifically engineered to withstand the shearing forces of fixed-blade and mechanical broadheads.

Because it is designed to be incredibly dense, it stops high-kinetic energy arrows with minimal penetration. This lack of deep penetration makes arrow extraction significantly easier compared to standard foam blocks. If the primary goal is a target that survives hundreds of shots without losing its structural integrity, this is the definitive choice.

Rinehart 18-1: Best for Easy Arrow Removal

The Rinehart 18-1 utilizes a signature self-healing foam that returns to its original form after an arrow is removed. This material property is vital for long-term target health, as it prevents the target from hollowing out or losing its stopping power in high-traffic zones.

This target features eighteen distinct aiming points, which helps distribute wear and prevents the “dead-center” burnout common in lesser models. While the initial cost is higher than basic foam blocks, the longevity offered by its self-healing capabilities makes it a sound financial decision. It is the ideal companion for those who demand a target that remains functional season after season.

Block 6×6: The Classic Layered Foam Target

The Block 6×6 employs a layered compression technology that uses friction to stop arrows rather than just force. When a broadhead enters the layers, the friction generates heat that helps the foam hold the shaft, making it effective for a wide range of bow speeds.

The modular design allows for easy target face replacements, meaning the core can be refreshed without needing a full unit replacement. It is a proven workhorse that performs reliably for both field points and broadheads. For the archer who prefers a tried-and-true system, the Block 6×6 offers a balanced mix of performance and straightforward maintenance.

SpyderWeb ST 18XL: Best for High-Speed Bows

The SpyderWeb ST 18XL is purpose-built for modern, high-speed compound bows that generate massive kinetic energy. Its internal stopping mechanism is designed to handle the friction of high-velocity broadheads without melting the target’s internal fibers.

Unlike traditional solid foam blocks, this model uses a specialized, tightly-woven material that stops arrows gracefully. This reduces the violent impact often felt by carbon arrows, which helps maintain the lifespan of expensive shafts. If a current setup involves a bow pushing speeds above 320 feet per second, this target is the premier solution for preventing pass-throughs.

Bulldog Doghouse Target: Top Value for Longevity

The Bulldog Doghouse is often recognized for its straightforward design and its impressive ability to handle heavy volume. It features a unique, thick foam core that is wrapped in a replaceable cover, effectively doubling the life of the target face.

The standout feature here is the ease of arrow removal, which requires minimal physical effort even after aggressive broadhead use. For hunters who practice daily leading up to the season, this target offers the best balance of cost-per-shot. It is a no-nonsense, durable tool that prioritizes utility over complex aesthetics.

Matrix Target: Most Innovative Self-Healing Foam

The Matrix Target utilizes a high-density, multi-layered foam matrix that is specifically designed to handle broadheads without “chunking.” Many targets suffer from material loss when a broadhead is twisted out, but this foam is engineered to keep its form.

Its modular build is highly effective at stopping arrows cleanly, preventing the dreaded “fletching drag” that can ruin accuracy. Because the foam is so dense, it does not require a bulky size to be effective, making it a great option for shooters with limited storage space. It is a highly refined target for those who appreciate design precision in their practice gear.

How to Choose the Right Broadhead Target Butt

Selecting the right target depends largely on the draw weight and arrow speed of your current bow. Higher speeds require denser foam to prevent the arrow from burying up to the fletchings, which makes removal a strenuous task. Consider the intended volume of practice; if the target will be left outside year-round, ensure the model is UV-resistant and weather-rated.

• Low-speed bows (under 280 fps): Standard layered foam targets are usually sufficient.
• High-speed bows (over 300 fps): Prioritize high-density, self-healing foam models to avoid pass-throughs.
• Space constraints: Look for compact, high-density blocks that offer multiple sides for shooting.

Foam vs. Bag Targets for Broadhead Practice

It is essential to understand that bag targets are intended exclusively for field points. Using a broadhead on a bag target will cause immediate, catastrophic damage by cutting the internal fill and ruining the target’s ability to hold together. Broadhead targets are constructed from solid, high-density foam blocks or self-healing materials to withstand the blade-slicing action.

Always keep these two categories separate to maintain both your equipment and your target’s lifespan. While bag targets are superior for long-range field point accuracy due to their size, broadheads require the structural integrity of a dedicated foam block. Mixing these uses usually results in broken arrows and a pile of unusable shredded fabric.

Pro Tips to Make Your Archery Target Last Longer

The longevity of any broadhead target is tied directly to how and where it is used. Rotate your target faces regularly to avoid concentrating all impacts on the center of the unit. If the target has multiple sides, cycle through them evenly to ensure the internal foam wears down at a consistent rate.

• Elevate the target: Keeping it off the damp ground prevents rot and maintains foam integrity.
• Cover it up: When not in use, store the target in a shed or under a tarp to protect it from harsh UV rays and precipitation.
• Consistent maintenance: Use a light coat of arrow lubricant on your shafts to make extraction easier and prevent internal foam tearing.

Safety Checklist for Sighting-In Broadheads

Sighting in broadheads is a high-stakes activity that requires focused attention to detail. Always ensure there is a massive backstop behind the target—such as a steep dirt berm—to catch any missed shots. Never attempt to shoot broadheads in a backyard environment where a stray arrow could leave the property boundary.

• Check blades: Ensure all broadhead blades are tightly secured and free of nicks before the first shot.
• Clear the area: Establish a strict perimeter to ensure no humans or pets enter the line of fire.
• Use proper tools: Always use an arrow puller or a dedicated grip to remove broadheads safely, keeping hands away from the blade edges.

Equipping yourself with a reliable broadhead target is an investment in your proficiency and success in the field. By choosing the right tool for your specific equipment, you ensure that your practice sessions remain safe, productive, and consistent. Take the time to dial in your gear, maintain your targets properly, and enjoy the confidence that comes with knowing your setup is ready for the season ahead.