6 Best Portable S’Mores Makers That Don’t Require a Campfire

The craving hits you on a Tuesday night, long after the sun has set. It’s the unmistakable desire for a gooey, fire-toasted s’more. But you’re on your apartment balcony, or a fire ban is in effect at your favorite campsite, or maybe it’s just raining. The classic campfire experience isn’t just about the gear; it’s about the moment, and sometimes you need to create that moment without the actual fire.

Disclosure: This site earns commissions from listed merchants at no cost to you. Thank you!

How to Pick the Perfect Portable S’mores Maker

Before you grab the first gadget you see, think about where and how you’ll be using it. Are you trying to entertain a gaggle of kids on a rainy Saturday? Or are you looking for a classier way to cap off a backyard barbecue? The right tool depends entirely on the mission.

Consider the core trade-offs. Safety is paramount, especially indoors or with little ones, which might push you toward a flameless electric option. If you’re all about that authentic, fire-charred marshmallow, you’ll need something with a real flame, which means thinking about fuel and ventilation.

Don’t forget about group size and cleanup. Some makers are designed for one-at-a-time roasting, perfect for a couple. Others are built to churn out a dozen gooey treats on the grill. Your choice comes down to a simple question: are you chasing the experience of roasting, or are you just after the delicious end result?

Nostalgia Electric for Safe, Flameless Roasting

Picture this: it’s a sleepover, and the kids are begging for s’mores, but a living room campfire is obviously out. This is where the electric s’mores maker shines. It’s essentially a small, focused heater with a protective grate, surrounded by trays for your graham crackers, chocolate, and marshmallows.

The biggest win here is safety. There’s no open flame, making it the undisputed champion for indoor use, dorm rooms, and supervised kid-friendly fun. The heating element provides consistent, gentle heat that melts the marshmallow perfectly. Cleanup is usually a breeze.

The trade-off is authenticity. You won’t get that smoky, caramelized crust you get from a real flame. It’s more of a "melter" than a "roaster." But when the alternative is no s’mores at all, this is a fantastic, safe, and reliable way to get your fix.

Sterno S’mores Maker for a Real Flame Feel

You’re on a covered deck or a picnic table at a campsite with a strict "no ground fires" rule. You want the real deal—the flicker of a flame, the fun of toasting your own marshmallow. The Sterno-based maker is your go-to for this scenario.

These simple devices consist of a base to hold a can of chafing fuel and a grate to rest your skewers on. It provides a real, controllable flame that’s perfect for achieving that golden-brown (or completely burnt, if that’s your style) marshmallow. It’s compact, easy to transport, and gives you the interactive experience everyone loves.

The primary consideration is that you’re still managing an open flame. Always use it in a well-ventilated area and away from flammable materials. You’ll also need a steady supply of fuel cans, which adds a small recurring cost. But for that classic campfire feel without the smoke and mess, it’s hard to beat.

City Bonfires: The All-in-One Portable Fire Pit

Imagine you’re car camping and a burn ban is in effect, but containerized fires are still allowed. Or maybe you just want a hassle-free fire in the backyard for 30 minutes. City Bonfires were made for this exact moment.

This clever product is a miniature bonfire in a tin. Made from non-toxic soy wax and paper briquettes, you simply light the corner and a small, cheerful fire comes to life. It delivers the crackle, the warmth, and the perfect flame for roasting, all in a self-contained, portable package.

This is the most authentic fire alternative, but it comes with trade-offs. It’s designed for a limited number of uses, so it’s not a permanent solution and can be less cost-effective over time. And because it’s a real fire, it is strictly for outdoor use on a heat-proof surface.

Solo Stove Mesa for Smokeless, Elegant Roasting

You’ve invited friends over for a backyard get-together and want to elevate the evening. You need something more permanent and polished than a can of fuel. The Solo Stove Mesa is a tabletop fire pit that brings performance and style to the party.

Using the same clever airflow design as its larger siblings, the Mesa burns small wood chunks or pellets with incredible efficiency, producing a beautiful flame with almost no smoke. It creates a fantastic centerpiece and provides the perfect heat for roasting marshmallows. It’s a durable, long-term piece of gear.

The investment is the biggest factor here. The Mesa is the priciest option on this list and requires a bit more effort—you need to supply the wood or pellets and clean out the ash afterward. But for a smokeless, reusable, and undeniably cool backyard s’mores station, it’s in a class of its own.

Chicago Metallic S’mores Maker for Oven or Grill

It’s grilling season, and you’re already cooking burgers and hot dogs over charcoal. Why not use that same heat for dessert? This s’mores maker isn’t a heat source itself, but rather a brilliant accessory for your existing oven or grill.

This tool is essentially a specially designed tray that holds all the s’mores components in place. You assemble your s’mores, lock them into the caddy, and place it on the grill or in the oven. In minutes, you have a half-dozen perfectly melted, uniform s’mores ready to serve.

The trade-off is clear: you sacrifice the entire experience of roasting for efficiency and convenience. There’s no stick, no flame, no toasting. This is a production tool, perfect for serving a crowd quickly without the mess.

Progressive Microwave Maker for Instant S’mores

The craving is sudden and intense. You’re in your pajamas, it’s late, and you need a s’more in the next 90 seconds. For maximum speed and minimum fuss, nothing beats a dedicated microwave s’mores maker.

This quirky little gadget is pure genius. You stack your graham, chocolate, and marshmallow, and place it in the microwave. As the marshmallow heats and expands, it pushes up a little arm that presses the whole thing together into a perfectly gooey sandwich.

You get the core flavors of a s’more almost instantly. The marshmallow texture is different—soft and puffy rather than toasted and crispy—but it absolutely satisfies the craving. It’s the ultimate tool for a quick, solo treat when convenience is the only thing that matters.

Comparing Fuel Types: Electric, Flame, and Microwave

Choosing the right maker boils down to the fuel source and the experience you want. Each has its place, whether on the trail, in the backyard, or on the kitchen counter.

• Electric: This is your indoor, safety-first option.

  • Best For: Families with young children, dorm rooms, rainy days.
  • Pros: No open flame, easy to use and clean, consistent heat.
  • Cons: Requires an outlet, doesn’t provide an authentic "toasted" flavor.

• Canned Heat & Small Fire Pits: This is for the authentic flame-roasting experience.

  • Best For: Patios, backyards, campsites with fire restrictions.
  • Pros: Real flame for a classic taste and feel, creates a great social centerpiece.
  • Cons: Requires ventilation and fire safety, needs a constant supply of fuel (cans, wood, or pellets).

• Microwave & Oven/Grill: These are your convenience and batch-making methods.

  • Best For: Instant gratification, serving a large group quickly.
  • Pros: Extremely fast and easy, uses appliances you already own.
  • Cons: Completely removes the interactive roasting process, alters marshmallow texture.

At the end of the day, the goal isn’t to own the most impressive gear. The goal is to share a moment and a delicious, gooey treat with people you care about. Whether it’s a perfectly charred marshmallow from a tabletop fire pit or a puffy, instant one from the microwave, the right s’mores maker is simply the one that gets you to that happy place. So pick the one that fits your life, and get melting.