7 Best Sale Fishing Flies For Dry Fly Fishing For When the Hatch Is Unclear

You’re standing waist-deep in a perfect run, the current whispering against your waders. You see the tell-tale rings of rising trout, but a glance at the water’s surface reveals… nothing. No flotilla of mayflies, no skittering caddis, just the occasional bubble and the dimple of a feeding fish.

Disclosure: This site earns commissions from listed merchants at no cost to you. Thank you!

Why Attractor Patterns Are Your Best Bet

When you can’t "match the hatch" because there’s no clear hatch to match, your best move is to tie on an attractor pattern. These flies aren’t designed to imitate a single, specific insect. Instead, they suggest a wide range of buggy-looking food sources—a mayfly, a caddis, a small terrestrial—all rolled into one.

The genius of an attractor is its ambiguity. It presents a general impression of life and food, triggering a trout’s opportunistic feeding instinct. Rather than waiting for a perfect imitation, a fish sees a high-floating, buggy silhouette and often decides it’s a meal worth grabbing before it gets away.

This approach isn’t a silver bullet for highly selective trout sipping on a specific insect in a slow, clear pool. But for most situations, especially when prospecting for fish or dealing with an unknown food source, an attractor is your most effective tool. It allows you to cover water with confidence, presenting something that looks alive and edible, which is often all it takes.

Parachute Adams: The Ultimate Mayfly Imitator

If you could only have one dry fly, a strong case could be made for the Parachute Adams. It’s the quintessential mayfly silhouette, with a gray body, mixed grizzly and brown hackle, and a tail that suggests a dun. Its most important feature is the white calf tail or poly yarn parachute post, which makes it incredibly easy to see on the water in various light conditions.

The parachute design allows the fly to sit low in the surface film, just like a natural mayfly emerging or struggling. This realistic presentation is deadly. Because its colors are so generic—a mix of gray, brown, and white—it can suggest nearly any mayfly, from a Blue-Winged Olive to a Hendrickson, just by changing the size.

Carry this fly in sizes 12 through 20. A size 14 or 16 is a perfect starting point for most streams. On a high mountain creek or a broad tailwater, the Parachute Adams is rarely the wrong choice when you see fish rising but aren’t sure what they’re eating.

Elk Hair Caddis: A High-Floating Classic

You’re fishing a stretch of river with faster currents and pocket water. A delicate mayfly pattern would get drowned in seconds. This is where the Elk Hair Caddis shines. Tied with a buoyant, hollow-fibered elk or deer hair wing, this fly is designed to float high and handle rough water with ease.

The Elk Hair Caddis perfectly imitates the tent-like wing profile of an adult caddisfly, one of the most abundant insects in trout streams worldwide. You can fish it dead-drifted, but it’s also incredibly effective when skated or twitched on the surface. This action mimics the frantic, skittering movement of a natural caddis laying its eggs, a behavior that can trigger explosive strikes from aggressive trout.

This is a must-have pattern from spring through fall. Its durability and high visibility make it a fantastic choice for beginners, while its effectiveness in fast water makes it a staple for experienced anglers. Tie one on when you need a fly that won’t quit, especially in the evening when caddis activity often peaks.

Royal Wulff: A Can’t-Miss Searcher Pattern

Sometimes, subtlety is overrated. When you need to grab a trout’s attention from a distance, the Royal Wulff is your fly. It’s a bushy, high-floating pattern with white calf-tail wings, a peacock herl body, and a bright red floss band in the middle. It looks like nothing in particular and a whole lot of things at once.

This is the definition of a searching pattern. Its purpose is to be seen. The bright colors and bulky profile draw fish up from the depths in fast, broken water where they have only a split second to decide whether to eat. The white wings are also a massive benefit to the angler, making the fly easy to track through glare and riffles.

The Royal Wulff excels in brawling freestone rivers and small, brushy streams where a precise imitation is less important than visibility and buoyancy. It suggests a big, clumsy terrestrial or a large mayfly, and it simply gets eaten. If you’re exploring new water and want to see if any aggressive fish are home, this is the fly to knock on the door with.

The Stimulator: A Big Meal for Eager Trout

Picture a big, tumbling western river in the middle of summer. The water is alive with stoneflies, grasshoppers, and other large insects. The Stimulator is the fly built for this environment. With its elk hair wing, heavily-hackled body, and bright orange or yellow abdomen, it’s a big, buggy meal that’s hard for a trout to ignore.

This pattern is a true multi-tool. In large sizes, it’s a fantastic imitation of an adult stonefly or a grasshopper. In smaller sizes, it can effectively pass for a large caddis. Its incredible buoyancy, thanks to the deer hair and dense hackle, also makes it one of the best flies to use as the top fly in a dry-dropper rig, where it can suspend a heavy nymph underneath without sinking.

The Stimulator is at its best when fished tight to the bank, under overhanging branches, or through choppy riffles. It’s a fly that says "easy calories," and it often coaxes larger, more reclusive trout out from their hiding places.

Griffith’s Gnat: For Midge Cluster Situations

You’re staring at a glassy pool on a calm day. All around you, trout are rising with slow, delicate sips, but you can’t see a single bug on the water. This is the classic sign of a midge hatch. Tying on a single, tiny midge imitation can be effective but also frustratingly hard to see. The Griffith’s Gnat is the solution.

This simple fly, made of just peacock herl wrapped with grizzly hackle, imitates a cluster of tiny midges stuck together on the surface film. This creates a more substantial target that is both easier for the trout to see and more appealing as a meal. It’s a small fly that fishes big.

The Griffith’s Gnat is an essential pattern for tailwaters and spring creeks where midges are a primary food source year-round. When you see those subtle, sipping rises, resist the urge to tie on a big attractor. Go small, tie on a Griffith’s Gnat, and present a mouthful of tiny insects the trout are actually looking for.

Chubby Chernobyl: The Ultimate Foam Attractor

Modern fly fishing has embraced foam, and for good reason. The Chubby Chernobyl is a prime example of why. This fly is virtually unsinkable, making it the king of turbulent water and the undisputed champion of dry-dropper rigs. Its foam body, poly yarn wing, and rubber legs create a profile that screams "food."

What is it imitating? Anything you want it to be. Depending on the size and color, it can pass for a giant stonefly, a cicada, a grasshopper, or a cricket. It’s a massive attractor that excels during the summer months when large terrestrial insects are frequently blown into the water. The Chubby floats so high that it can support even the heaviest tungsten bead-head nymphs.

This is not a delicate fly for spooky fish in flat water. This is a workhorse for covering big water, fishing deep runs with a nymph below, and tempting the largest, most opportunistic fish in the river. If you want to fish a "hopper-dropper" rig with confidence, the Chubby is your fly.

The Humpy: A High-Riding, Buggy Attractor

The Humpy is an old-school pattern that has remained a staple for a simple reason: it works. Constructed with a hollow deer hair overbody, or "hump," it traps air and floats like a cork. This design makes it an excellent choice for the most turbulent pocket water and fastest riffles, where lesser flies would be immediately submerged.

Like the Royal Wulff, the Humpy is a generalist. Its buggy, high-riding silhouette can suggest a caddis, a small stonefly, or a beetle. It comes in various colors, with yellow and red being the most popular, allowing you to roughly match the general tone of the prevalent insects on any given day.

This is a go-to fly for small stream and mountain fishing. Its durability and extreme buoyancy mean you spend more time fishing and less time changing flies or applying floatant. When the water is fast and you need a fly that will stay on top and get noticed, the Humpy is a proven winner.

Don’t let the mystery of an unclear hatch keep you on the bank. Stocking your box with these seven patterns gives you a versatile toolkit for nearly any situation. The most important piece of gear is the confidence to get out there, observe the water, and make a smart choice. Now go fish.