6 Best Prop Baits For Aggressive Strikes That Draw Fish From Heavy Cover

Imagine a thick mat of lily pads baking in the summer sun, with dark pockets of shadow underneath. You know a big bass is in there, but a worm or jig would get lost in the salad. This is the moment to tie on a lure that calls fish out of hiding with pure, unadulterated noise.

Disclosure: This site earns commissions from listed merchants at no cost to you. Thank you!

Why Prop Baits Excel in Heavy Cover Conditions

When fish bury themselves in dense vegetation, submerged timber, or under docks, they rely on sound and vibration to hunt. A prop bait is designed to create a massive surface disturbance. The spinning blades chop, gurgle, and spit water, creating a commotion that fish can detect from a surprising distance.

This auditory trigger is the key. A bass lurking deep in a weed bed might not see a lure passing overhead, but it will absolutely hear and feel the rhythmic splash of a prop bait. This sound mimics struggling prey—like a small bird, a frantic baitfish, or a frog—which triggers an aggressive, territorial, or predatory response. They don’t just come to investigate; they come to destroy the source of the noise.

Different prop baits offer different sound profiles. Single props provide a more subtle fizz, double props create a ripping sound, and plopper-style baits generate a deep, rhythmic thumping. The right choice depends on water conditions and fish mood, but they all share one goal: making enough noise to convince a hidden fish that an easy meal is passing by.

Heddon Baby Torpedo: A Timeless Topwater Classic

If you’re staring at a calm, glassy surface near a laydown or a patch of sparse reeds, the Heddon Baby Torpedo is a perfect choice. This lure has been fooling bass for generations for a reason: its subtlety is its strength. The single, rear-mounted prop creates a gentle fizzing and spitting sound that doesn’t spook wary fish.

The Torpedo’s magic lies in its simplicity and the angler’s cadence. It’s not a lure for burning across the water. Cast it past your target, let the ripples settle, and then give it a short, sharp twitch. The prop sputters to life, creating a bubble trail. Then pause. The strike almost always comes when the bait is sitting perfectly still.

This bait is lightweight, affordable, and incredibly effective, making it a fantastic entry point into the world of prop baits. It teaches the importance of the pause and proves that sometimes, less commotion is more effective, especially in clear or calm water where fish have more time to inspect a lure.

Smithwick Devil’s Horse: The Go-To Double Prop

When you need to dial up the noise and cover water along the edge of a weed line, the Smithwick Devil’s Horse is the classic answer. With props on both the front and back, this lure can be worked aggressively to create a significant ripping sound and a V-wake that draws attention. It’s a legendary bait, particularly during the prespawn when bass are territorial and guarding beds.

The slender, minnow-like profile of the Devil’s Horse is a key feature. While the props create chaos, the body shape suggests a vulnerable baitfish. This combination is deadly. You can work it with a twitch-twitch-pause retrieve to make it dart and sputter, or you can "rip" it with a long sweep of the rod to make the props churn violently.

This dual-prop design gives you versatility. A slow retrieve makes it a subtle target, while a fast, aggressive one turns it into a search bait that calls fish from afar. It’s a workhorse lure that has a place in any topwater angler’s tackle box, bridging the gap between subtle and explosive presentations.

River2Sea Whopper Plopper for Maximum Commotion

When the wind picks up and there’s a chop on the water, or you need to call fish out of the thickest cover imaginable, the Whopper Plopper is the tool for the job. This isn’t a traditional prop bait; its rotating tail creates a deep, resonant "plop-plop-plop" that is unlike anything else. That unique sound travels an incredible distance underwater.

The beauty of the Whopper Plopper is its ease of use. A simple, steady retrieve is all it takes to get the tail spinning and the sound echoing through the water. This makes it an excellent choice for anglers of all skill levels and a highly efficient tool for covering vast flats or long stretches of shoreline to locate active fish.

This bait excels at triggering pure reaction strikes. The consistent, hypnotic sound can annoy a neutral fish into biting or convince a feeding fish that a substantial meal is escaping. While it can be too aggressive for calm, clear conditions, it is an unparalleled choice for creating a disturbance that simply cannot be ignored.

Jackall Choppo: A Refined Plopping Presentation

For anglers who love the plopping sound but want a slightly different acoustic signature, the Jackall Choppo is a fantastic alternative. It offers a similar plopping-style action but produces a sound that is often described as a bit higher-pitched or more "clacky" than its competitors. On highly pressured lakes where fish have seen and heard everything, this subtle difference can be the key to getting bit.

The Choppo is exceptionally well-balanced, allowing it to run true at almost any retrieval speed, from a slow crawl to a fast burn. This versatility lets you fine-tune your presentation on the fly. Its durable tail is designed to withstand vicious strikes and keep spinning correctly, cast after cast.

Available in multiple sizes, the Choppo allows you to match the lure to the conditions and the forage. The smaller 90 size is perfect for a more finesse approach, while the larger 120 model creates a massive disturbance to attract the biggest predators in the area. It’s a refined, high-performance take on the plopper concept.

Megabass I-Loud: A Premium Jointed Prop Bait

When you’re looking for a lure that throws everything but the kitchen sink at a fish, you’ve found it in the Megabass I-Loud. This is a premium, complex bait designed for one thing: triggering massive strikes from wise, trophy-sized bass. It combines a rear prop, a jointed body, and a unique internal sound system into one incredibly loud package.

The I-Loud features a "Rudder Action Balancer System," where an internal weight swings side-to-side, striking the walls of the lure and creating a loud, deep knocking sound. This is paired with the surface splash of the prop and the subtle swimming action of the jointed body. The result is a lure that appeals to a fish’s senses of hearing, sight, and vibration all at once.

The clear tradeoff here is cost. This is an expensive, highly specialized lure. It’s not the bait you throw into a thick maze of submerged branches. But for open water adjacent to heavy cover or for targeting big, suspended fish that have ignored other topwaters, the I-Loud offers a complex and powerful presentation that is truly in a class of its own.

Cotton Cordell Boy Howdy: Unbeatable Value & Action

Proving that legendary fish-catching action doesn’t have to come with a high price tag, the Cotton Cordell Boy Howdy is a must-have for any angler. This classic double-prop bait delivers a frantic, sputtering action that has been effective for decades. It’s a simple, no-frills lure that just plain works.

The Boy Howdy excels with a twitch-and-pause cadence. Two or three quick snaps of the rod tip make the props churn and spit, perfectly imitating a flailing baitfish. Then, let it sit still. That pause is often when a bass that was tracking the lure decides to commit.

Its greatest strength is its value. You can stock your box with several Boy Howdy lures in different colors for the price of one premium bait. This makes it the perfect choice for probing risky areas—casting it right next to logs, under overhanging trees, and into thick brush where losing a lure is a real possibility.

Mastering Cadence to Trigger Explosive Strikes

Owning the best prop baits is only half the battle; knowing how to use them is what triggers the strike. Cadence—the rhythm and speed of your retrieve—is everything. With traditional prop baits like the Torpedo and Devil’s Horse, the pause is your most powerful weapon. The commotion draws their attention, but the sudden stop signals vulnerability. Experiment with the length of your pause, from one second to ten, until you find what the fish want.

Plopper-style baits like the Whopper Plopper and Choppo are different. They are often most effective on a steady retrieve that maintains their signature sound. However, don’t be afraid to experiment. Sometimes, briefly killing the retrieve and letting the bait float for a second is all it takes to make a following fish bite. A sudden burst of speed can also trigger a strike from a fish that was just lazily trailing behind.

Ultimately, let the fish and the conditions guide you. On windy days, a faster, louder retrieve is needed to get noticed. On calm mornings, a slower, more deliberate twitch-and-pause might be the ticket. Pay attention to every cast, vary your cadence, and you’ll turn those follows into explosive, heart-stopping strikes.

Don’t get bogged down by having the "perfect" lure for every situation. Pick one or two of these proven designs, learn their unique sounds and cadences, and focus on getting them in front of fish. The best prop bait is the one you have tied on, making a racket near heavy cover.