7 Trolling Motor Shear Pin Replacements for Quick On-the-Water Fixes

You’re silently working a weed line when you feel a solid thump from your trolling motor, followed by a high-pitched whirring sound. The boat stops moving, but the motor is still running. That sinking feeling is the tell-tale sign of a broken shear pin, a tiny part designed to be the sacrificial hero that saves your motor’s expensive internals from a submerged stump or rock. Having the right spare pin and knowing how to use it is the difference between a 5-minute fix and a frustrating paddle back to the ramp.

Disclosure: This site earns commissions from listed merchants at no cost to you. Thank you!

Diagnosing a Broken Trolling Motor Shear Pin

Picture this: you’re using your spot-lock feature to hold steady over a brush pile, and a sudden gust of wind pushes you into a submerged log. The motor revs, but your propeller is dead in the water. That’s the classic symptom. A broken shear pin means the motor shaft spins freely, but the propeller, which is connected via that small pin, doesn’t receive any power.

A shear pin is a simple metal or composite rod that passes through the propeller and the motor’s driveshaft, held in place by a prop nut. It’s engineered to be the weakest link in the system. When your prop hits something solid, the pin is designed to snap, or shear, absorbing the impact force that would otherwise travel up the shaft and potentially damage the motor’s armature or seals—a far more catastrophic and expensive failure.

Many anglers are tempted to use a "stronger" substitute, like a piece of a nail or a stainless steel screw, thinking it will prevent future breaks. This is a critical mistake. A pin that doesn’t break under impact transfers all that damaging force directly to the motor’s core components. Using the correct, manufacturer-specified shear pin is non-negotiable insurance for your motor’s health. Think of it as a fuse for your trolling motor; you wouldn’t replace a 15-amp fuse with a 30-amp one, and the same logic applies here.

Minn Kota MKP-8: The Go-To for Minn Kota Motors

If you’re running a Minn Kota—from an Endura on your jon boat to an Ultrex on a high-end bass rig—the MKP-8 prop nut and washer kit is your baseline spare part. There’s little reason to look elsewhere. Minn Kota designed this composite pin specifically to shear at the precise force needed to protect their motors. It’s the factory-standard part for a reason.

The MKP-8 kit is designed for props with a 3-1/4" hub diameter, which covers a massive range of their most popular motors. The pin itself is a dark, hardened composite material. It’s not metal. This is intentional, as the composite material provides a predictable and clean break, unlike a metal pin that might bend and deform, making it difficult to remove from the prop shaft on the water.

Having a couple of these kits stashed in a dry box or a glove compartment is one of the smartest, cheapest investments an angler can make. The peace of mind that comes from having the exact OEM part when you’re miles from the launch is invaluable. It removes all guesswork and ensures you aren’t voiding a warranty or risking your motor with an improper substitute.

MotorGuide MGA050B6 for Xi, X & Tour Series

For the dedicated MotorGuide user, the MGA050B6 propeller kit is the equivalent of the Minn Kota standard. It’s the OEM-specified part for their most popular modern motors, including the Xi3, Xi5, X3, X5, and Tour series. Sticking with the manufacturer’s part ensures perfect compatibility and protects the sensitive electronics and internal gearing of these advanced motors.

This kit typically includes the shear pin, prop nut, and washer. The pin is engineered to match the torque and thrust output of MotorGuide’s props, like the Machete series. Using a generic pin might work in a pinch, but it won’t have the same shear-strength characteristics, putting your motor at unnecessary risk during an impact.

Whether you’re navigating a stumpy reservoir with a Tour Pro or holding position over open-water structure with an Xi5, a hard prop strike is always a possibility. The cost of a genuine MotorGuide pin kit is negligible compared to the potential repair bill for a damaged motor shaft or lower unit. Keep one in your boat’s emergency kit, right next to your spare drain plug and basic tool set.

TH Marine Prop Nut/Pin Kit for Universal Fits

Sometimes you just need a part that works, right now. The TH Marine Prop Nut/Pin Kit is the universal soldier of shear pin replacements. It’s an excellent choice for an angler’s "just-in-case" tackle box, especially if you fish on different boats or with friends who run various brands. It’s designed to fit most Minn Kota and MotorGuide motors, among others.

The main advantage here is versatility and cost-effectiveness. The pins are often simple, straight metal rods that can be cut to length if needed. This makes them a fantastic backup option to get you through the day if you’ve already used your OEM spare. They are a get-you-home solution.

However, the tradeoff for that universality is a lack of precision engineering. A universal metal pin may not shear at the exact same force as a brand-specific composite pin. While it’s far better than using a nail, it may not offer the same level of protection as the part designed specifically for your motor. Consider this your reliable backup, but always try to replace it with the proper OEM pin when you get back to shore.

Newport Vessels Propeller Pin for NV Series

Newport Vessels has carved out a significant space in the market, especially for kayak anglers and owners of smaller watercraft. If you’re running one of their popular NV Series motors, sticking with a Newport Vessels-specific propeller pin is the smart play. These motors, while durable, are built to be lightweight and efficient, and their components are matched accordingly.

These pins are designed to protect the more compact lower units found on motors with thrust ratings typically between 36 and 86 pounds. The forces involved are different from those on a 112-pound thrust motor on a heavy fiberglass boat. Using a pin that’s too strong could easily damage the shaft on these smaller, lighter motors.

The cost is minimal, and ordering a few directly from Newport Vessels or their distributors when you buy the motor is a simple, proactive step. For a kayak angler exploring shallow, rocky rivers or stump-filled coves, a prop strike isn’t a matter of if, but when. Having the right pin ensures your day of fishing isn’t cut short by a long, frustrating paddle against the current.

Watersnake Propeller Pins for Saltwater Use

Anglers plying the coastal flats and inshore estuaries know that saltwater is relentless. It corrodes everything. For those running Watersnake motors, a brand popular for its saltwater-ready designs, using their specific propeller pins is crucial for longevity. These pins are often made with corrosion-resistant materials to withstand the harsh marine environment.

Watersnake motors, like the popular Shadow or Geo-Spot series, are built with stainless steel shafts and coated components. The shear pin is part of that system. Using a standard steel pin from a freshwater kit will lead to it rusting and potentially seizing inside the prop shaft, creating a massive headache when you actually need to replace it.

The key consideration here is material integrity. A dedicated Watersnake pin is designed not just to shear correctly but also to survive constant exposure to salt spray and submersion. It’s a small detail that makes a big difference in the maintenance and reliability of your gear over a long season of coastal fishing.

Haswing Trolling Motor Pins for Cayman Models

Haswing trolling motors, particularly the Cayman bow-mount series, have gained a following for offering advanced features like GPS anchoring at an accessible price point. Just like with other specialized motors, the integrity of the system relies on using matched components, and the shear pin is no exception.

The pins for Haswing motors are sized and specified for their unique propeller and shaft designs. The Cayman series, for example, is often used on boats where precise maneuverability is key. A prop strike while navigating tight docks or shallow oyster beds is a common scenario. Having the correct pin ensures the motor is protected and you can get back to fishing quickly.

Because Haswing is a more specialized brand than the industry giants, finding pins at a local big-box store can be a challenge. It’s wise for Haswing owners to order several spare pins online and keep them on the boat at all times. This foresight prevents a great day on the water from being ruined by a simple, but hard-to-find, part.

Seachoice Stainless Steel Pins for Durability

In some specific, high-abuse situations, an angler might consider a more durable pin. Seachoice and other aftermarket brands offer stainless steel shear pins that are significantly stronger than OEM composite or standard metal pins. This is a specialized choice for a very specific problem.

Who should consider this? An angler who navigates extremely thick, matted vegetation—like hydrilla or milfoil—day in and day out. In these conditions, the constant resistance can sometimes shear weaker composite pins prematurely, even without a hard impact. A stainless steel pin can provide more durability against this type of chronic, low-grade stress.

However, this choice comes with a major tradeoff and a significant risk. A stainless steel pin will not shear as easily upon a hard impact with a rock or stump. This means the damaging force is more likely to be transferred to the motor shaft, seals, or armature, potentially causing a failure that costs hundreds of dollars to repair. This is an expert-level decision for those who understand the risks and have decided the benefit of fewer breaks in heavy weeds outweighs the increased danger of catastrophic motor damage. For 99% of anglers, the OEM pin is the safer, smarter choice.

At the end of the day, a trolling motor shear pin is a tiny, inexpensive piece of gear that plays an outsized role in keeping you on the water. Don’t overthink it, but don’t ignore it. Grab the right spare for your motor, learn the two-minute process of changing it, and toss it in a waterproof box so it’s there when you need it. Preparation is what allows you to forget about your gear and focus on the fish.