6 Best Bowfishing Arrows For Carp That Withstand Tough Underwater Hits

The line sings off your reel as the arrow streaks through the murky water, a perfect shot on a big common carp. You feel the satisfying thump as it connects, but it’s not the soft impact of fish flesh. It’s the jarring crack of your arrow hitting a submerged boulder right behind the carp, which spooks and vanishes in a cloud of silt. A quick retrieve confirms your fear: a snapped shaft and a lost point, ending your night early. Choosing the right bowfishing arrow isn’t just about hitting the fish; it’s about surviving the miss.

Disclosure: This site earns commissions from listed merchants at no cost to you. Thank you!

Key Features of a Durable Carp Bowfishing Arrow

When you’re hunting carp, you’re not just shooting at fish. You’re shooting at rocky bottoms, sunken logs, concrete riprap, and all sorts of arrow-destroying hazards hidden just beneath the surface. A durable arrow starts with the shaft material. Solid fiberglass is the old-school king of toughness, bending where others break, while carbon is lighter and straighter for better accuracy but can shatter on a hard impact. The sweet spot for many is a carbon composite, which wraps a stiff carbon core in a durable fiberglass shell, giving you a great blend of both worlds.

Beyond the shaft, look at the nock system. A cheap, poorly glued nock can pop off when the arrow passes through a fish or gets yanked sideways from a snag. Look for arrows with robust, integrated nocks or systems designed to withstand the unique, multi-directional forces of bowfishing. A lost nock means a lost arrow, plain and simple.

Finally, the connection between the point and the shaft is a major failure point. A well-designed arrow will have a solid shoulder for the point to seat against, preventing the shaft from splitting on impact. Whether the point is fixed or has a replaceable tip, that junction must be rock-solid. This is where a budget arrow often fails first, so investing in a quality build here pays off immediately.

Muzzy Carbon Composite for All-Around Reliability

Imagine you’re stalking the banks of a slow-moving river, with opportunities ranging from carp in the muddy shallows to some cruising near a logjam. You need an arrow that can handle both a soft-bottom shot and a potential ricochet off timber. This is where the Muzzy Carbon Composite shines as a fantastic do-it-all workhorse.

Its construction is the key to its versatility. The carbon inner shaft provides the rigidity and straightness needed for consistent, accurate shots. That core is then wrapped in heavy-duty fiberglass, which provides the impact resistance to survive glancing blows off rocks and stumps that would splinter a pure carbon arrow. It’s a balanced design that doesn’t force you to choose between pinpoint accuracy and field-ready toughness. For the bowfisher who hits a variety of spots and wants one arrow they can trust everywhere, this is a top contender.

AMS Chaos FX for Maximum Penetration on Big Fish

You’ve spotted a true giant—a grass carp over 40 pounds, its thick, armor-like scales shimmering just below the surface. This isn’t a shot for a lightweight arrow that might bounce off. You need an arrow built to punch through and hold on, and the AMS Chaos FX is engineered for exactly this kind of encounter.

The power comes from its solid fiberglass construction. The sheer mass of the shaft carries tremendous kinetic energy, helping it drive deep through water and tough scales. This weight is paired with the formidable Chaos FX point, which features a super-short design and pivoting barbs. This combination ensures maximum penetration before the barbs engage, grabbing a massive amount of flesh for superior holding power on powerful fish. It’s not the fastest arrow, but when you connect with a trophy, you want penetration and holding power over all else.

Cajun Archery Piranha for Its Rugged Build

Think about the nastiest bowfishing environment you can find. We’re talking about shooting down into the tangled, submerged roots of a cypress swamp or skipping arrows off concrete spillways where carp congregate. This is a place where gear gets destroyed, and it’s the perfect territory for the Cajun Archery Piranha.

The Piranha arrow is built with one primary goal in mind: brute durability. It typically features a solid fiberglass shaft that prioritizes toughness over everything else. It might be a bit heavier and have more flex than a high-performance carbon arrow, but it’s designed to be abused. Paired with the classic Piranha point—a simple, tough-as-nails design—this arrow is made to withstand repeated impacts against hard cover. It’s the choice for bowfishers who measure a good night by how much abuse their gear survived, not by how fast their arrows fly.

Fin-Finder Heavy Metal for Deep Water Power Shots

You’re on a clear reservoir, and the carp are holding deep, suspended 10 feet down over an old creek channel. A standard, lightweight arrow loses energy fast as it pushes through that much water, often hitting with a weak thud that fails to penetrate. For these deep shots, you need an arrow that defies water resistance, and the Fin-Finder Heavy Metal is built for the job.

The secret is its significant weight. This arrow is a heavyweight contender, using its mass to maintain momentum on its journey to the target. Where a lighter arrow gets slowed and pushed off course by the water, the Heavy Metal plows through with authority, arriving with the power needed to bury the point deep. This makes it an ideal choice for anyone consistently shooting in clear, deep water where long-range power is the difference between a solid hold and a missed opportunity.

RPM Bowfishing Breakaway to Save Arrows in Snags

Here’s a scenario every bowfisher dreads: you make a great shot on a fish, but it immediately dives into a thicket of underwater branches or a mess of riprap. As you pull, the line goes tight, and you can feel your arrow shaft bending to its breaking point against the snag. The RPM Bowfishing Breakaway arrow is the ingenious solution to this exact problem.

This arrow’s magic is in its tip system. The point is designed to completely detach from the arrow shaft when subjected to extreme side pressure. Instead of your entire arrow snapping in half, the tip breaks away, staying connected to your line and the fish. You can then fight the fish and retrieve your valuable point, leaving only the replaceable shaft behind in the snag. For anyone who fishes in snag-infested waters, this innovative design can be a huge money and frustration saver over the course of a season.

TruGlo Titan‘s Spring-Loaded Tip for Hard Hits

You’re wading a shallow, gravel-bottomed creek at night, and the carp are everywhere. The problem is, nearly every shot that misses the fish results in a direct, head-on impact with the rocky creek bed. This is brutal on arrow points, mushrooming the tips and sending shockwaves up the shaft that can cause it to fail.

The TruGlo Titan addresses this with a clever, spring-loaded point. The hardened steel tip is backed by a powerful spring, creating a shock-absorbing system. When the arrow slams into a rock, the spring compresses, dissipating a significant amount of the impact energy that would otherwise be transferred to the shaft. This not only saves your arrow from potential fracture but also dramatically increases the lifespan of the point itself. It’s a specialized tool that provides a massive advantage for those who frequently hunt in shallow, hard-bottomed environments.

Matching Arrow Points to Your Bowfishing Style

An arrow shaft is ultimately a delivery vehicle; the point is what does the business of penetrating and holding the fish. While many of the arrows listed come with excellent stock points, understanding the different types allows you to customize your setup for peak performance. Your choice of point should be dictated by your target species and the environment you’re in.

The "best" point is always the one that matches the conditions. A few common styles cover most situations:

• Grapple or Shure Shot Points: These have wide, fixed barbs that are great for softer-fleshed fish like common carp and buffalo. They are simple, reliable, and generally easy to remove from the fish.
• Piranha or Garpoon Points: With tougher, more streamlined designs, these points excel at penetrating the hard scales of fish like gar and grass carp. They often require twisting to remove.
• Mechanical or Pivoting Barb Points: Designs like the AMS Chaos or Muzzy Trocar feature barbs that lie flat for maximum penetration and then pivot or expand on the retrieve for incredible holding power. These are excellent for big, powerful fish where a solid hold is non-negotiable.

Remember, you can often put your favorite style of point on your preferred arrow shaft. Don’t be afraid to mix and match to create the perfect setup for your next trip. The key is to build a system where a durable shaft is paired with a point that’s up to the task.

At the end of the day, the perfect, indestructible arrow doesn’t exist. Every shot into the water is a gamble. The goal is to choose gear that stacks the odds in your favor based on where and how you fish. Don’t get so caught up in the specs that you forget the real mission: getting out on the water. Grab the arrows that best fit your budget and your local spot, and go make some memories.