6 Best Sharpening Oils For Whetstones That Extend Stone Life

You’re deep in the backcountry, prepping dinner after a long day on the trail, and your knife is mashing the tomato instead of slicing it. A dull blade isn’t just frustrating; it’s a safety hazard. Proper sharpening is a fundamental skill, and the secret to doing it right—and making your whetstone last for years—is using the right honing oil.

Disclosure: This site earns commissions from listed merchants at no cost to you. Thank you!

Why Using Honing Oil Extends Your Whetstone’s Life

When you’re sharpening a knife on a whetstone, you’re scraping away microscopic particles of steel. This metal dust, called "swarf," has to go somewhere. Without oil, it gets packed directly into the pores of your stone.

Think of your whetstone like a file with thousands of tiny teeth. If those teeth get clogged with metal, the stone stops cutting and starts polishing. You’ll find yourself applying more pressure, getting poor results, and potentially gouging or cracking the stone.

Honing oil solves this problem elegantly. It creates a thin film on the surface, lifting and suspending the swarf so it can’t clog the stone’s pores. A quick wipe removes the metal-filled slurry, exposing a fresh, sharp cutting surface and ensuring your stone works efficiently for decades.

Norton Sharpening Stone Oil for All-Purpose Use

If there’s a classic, no-nonsense option found in workshops and gear sheds everywhere, it’s Norton’s oil. This is a highly refined mineral oil designed specifically for sharpening. Its job is to provide lubrication and float away swarf, and it does that job exceptionally well.

This oil has the perfect viscosity—not too thick to get gummy, and not so thin that it runs right off the stone. It’s the ideal partner for traditional oil stones like aluminum oxide (India) or silicon carbide (Crystolon) stones, which are often used for putting a tough, working edge on axes, machetes, and heavy-duty camp knives.

The key consideration here is that it’s a petroleum product and not rated as food-safe. After sharpening a tool with Norton oil, you’ll want to clean the blade thoroughly before it comes anywhere near your food. For general tool maintenance, it’s an industry standard for a reason.

Lansky Nathan’s Natural Honing Oil for Versatility

Many outdoor enthusiasts get their start with a guided sharpening system, and Lansky is one of the most recognizable names in that space. Their Nathan’s Natural Honing Oil is formulated to work perfectly with the variety of stones found in their kits, from synthetic abrasives to natural Arkansas stones.

This is another mineral-oil-based product, but it’s particularly well-suited for achieving fine, polished edges. Its light consistency is excellent for higher-grit stones, where preventing clogging is absolutely critical for getting a razor-sharp finish on your favorite bushcrafting knife or fillet knife.

Because it’s designed for versatility, it’s a great single-bottle solution if you own a mix of different stone types. Like most dedicated honing oils, it is not considered food-safe, so it’s best reserved for your utility blades rather than your primary camp kitchen knife.

DMT Dia-Sharp Fluid for Diamond & Arkansas Stones

Out on the trail, diamond sharpeners are king. They’re lightweight, cut aggressively, and don’t need to be flattened. But they still benefit from a lubricant, and that’s where a specialized fluid like DMT’s comes in.

Diamond plates don’t have pores like traditional stones, but swarf can still load up the surface, reducing cutting efficiency. While water works, a dedicated fluid like this does a better job of lifting steel particles and, crucially, contains rust inhibitors to protect the steel plate your diamonds are bonded to. It’s extremely thin, preventing any sort of film that might interfere with the diamonds’ cutting action.

This fluid is also an outstanding choice for very hard, fine-grained natural stones like black or translucent Arkansas stones. On these dense stones, a thick oil can sometimes feel like it’s slowing down the sharpening process. The light viscosity of the DMT fluid provides the necessary lubrication without getting in the way.

Smith’s HON1 for Preventing Clogging on Stones

Picture that old whetstone in your garage that’s dark and glazed over from years of use. Smith’s HON1 Honing Solution is engineered to prevent exactly that. It’s a petroleum-based lubricant that includes special cleaning agents in its formula.

This dual-action nature makes it a great choice for both active sharpening and stone maintenance. As you sharpen, it effectively lifts swarf, and if your stone is already a bit clogged, the solution helps break down and clear out that embedded material, restoring the stone’s cutting ability.

This is a fantastic all-rounder for the person maintaining a wide range of tools, from garden shears to pocket knives. It’s a reliable workhorse fluid. Just remember its petroleum base means it’s strictly for non-kitchen tools.

Howard Cutting Board Oil: The Food-Safe Option

So what do you use for the knife that slices your apples on a day hike or dices onions for your backcountry stew? The answer isn’t a dedicated honing oil, but something much simpler: food-grade mineral oil. Howard Cutting Board Oil is a widely available, trusted brand that’s perfect for the job.

This product is 100% pure, food-grade mineral oil, enriched with Vitamin E. It’s colorless, odorless, and tasteless, making it completely safe for any blade that will touch your food. You can use it on your whetstone, sharpen your knife, give the blade a quick wipe, and use it for dinner without a second thought.

The tradeoff is that it lacks the specialized cleaning agents of some dedicated honing oils. However, it performs the primary task of lubrication and swarf suspension perfectly well. For anyone sharpening kitchen cutlery or their primary camp cooking knife, using a food-safe mineral oil is the only responsible choice.

Tri-Flow Lubricant: A Multi-Use Workshop Solution

Sometimes, the best tool is the one you already have. Tri-Flow is a common high-performance lubricant found in many workshops, known for its penetrating ability and PTFE (Teflon) additives. In a pinch, it can absolutely be used as a honing oil.

It’s a light, petroleum-based oil that will do the essential job of floating away metal particles from your stone’s surface. This makes it a workable option for quick touch-ups on an axe or a utility tool when you don’t have dedicated honing oil on hand.

However, it’s not a perfect substitute. The additives, particularly PTFE, are not designed for whetstones and could potentially clog the pores of very fine-grit stones over time. It’s a classic "good enough for now" solution for coarse or medium stones, but you wouldn’t want to use it on your high-end finishing stones. And it goes without saying: this is not for use on food-prep blades.

Choosing Between Mineral, Petroleum, & Synthetic Oils

Navigating the options can feel complicated, but it boils down to matching the oil to your stone and your blade’s intended use. Your choice will generally fall into one of three categories.

Mineral Oil is the foundation. It can be a highly-refined, purpose-built product like Norton’s, or a simple, food-grade version like Howard’s. It’s predictable, effective, and the traditional choice for natural stones like Arkansas stones. Its main decision point is food safety.

Petroleum-Based Blends are the workhorses. Products from Smith’s or general lubricants like Tri-Flow fall here. They often contain extra detergents or additives to help clean the stone or improve lubrication. These are excellent for general-purpose tools and for reviving old, clogged stones, but should be kept away from kitchen knives.

Synthetic Fluids & Water represent the modern and specialized options. DMT’s fluid is engineered for diamond plates, offering rust protection and an ultra-thin lubricant. This category also includes water, which is the only lubricant you should use on Japanese water stones, as oil will permanently ruin them.

• For kitchen knives: Use food-grade mineral oil. No exceptions.
• For traditional oil stones (India, Crystolon): A dedicated mineral or petroleum-based honing oil is perfect.
• For diamond plates: Water works, but a dedicated fluid with a rust inhibitor is better.
• For Japanese water stones: Use only water.

Ultimately, a sharp tool is a safe, efficient tool, and keeping your whetstone clean is the surest way to get that perfect edge. Don’t get bogged down in finding the single "best" oil; instead, pick the right one for the job at hand. A little maintenance on your sharpening gear ensures it will be ready when you need it, letting you focus less on your tools and more on the view from the summit.